Assessing Network Redundancy: MPLS, SD-WAN, and SASE Compared

July 11, 2024
Assessing Network Redundancy: MPLS, SD-WAN, and SASE Compared

In today’s digital age, businesses hinge on the perpetual availability of their IT infrastructure. Network downtime, even for a minute, can result in staggering losses, amounting to over $14,000 depending on the company size and industry vertical. Such high stakes necessitate a reliable and resilient network infrastructure. This article delves into network redundancy—particularly across MPLS (Multiprotocol Label Switching), SD-WAN (Software-Defined Wide Area Network), and SASE (Secure Access Service Edge)—highlighting their significance, common themes, key points, and broader trends. Understanding the various approaches to network redundancy can help organizations make informed decisions that ensure business continuity, enhance employee productivity, and improve customer experiences.

The Importance of Network Redundancy

Network redundancy is paramount for achieving high network availability. It addresses multiple critical factors: reliability is the foremost consideration. Network redundancy eliminates single points of failure, ensuring that a backup path exists for data transmission if the primary path fails. This feature is crucial for maintaining business operations without interruptions. Downtime minimization is another significant aspect. During disruptions, a redundant network guarantees business continuity, preventing service outages that could otherwise paralyze operations and lead to financial losses and productivity declines. Employee productivity also benefits from a redundant network. Network issues affecting access to critical resources can severely hinder work, disrupting workflows, and reducing overall efficiency.

Furthermore, a seamless customer experience is critical. Ensuring uninterrupted network service means customers can access online platforms without experiencing delays or downtimes, which can damage brand reputation and customer loyalty. Security also plays a vital role in network redundancy. Redundant paths ensure that, during a security incident, data can still flow through secure alternative routes, mitigating the impact on business operations. In light of these considerations, it becomes evident that implementing a robust redundancy strategy is not only a measure of technological sophistication but a necessity for safeguarding business interests in a hyper-connected world.

MPLS Redundancy: Reliable Backbone, Vulnerable Last Mile

MPLS has built a reputation for its reliable and fast connectivity, largely due to its inherent network redundancy. There are several key points to consider: MPLS carriers provide built-in redundancy paths within their infrastructure. This built-in carrier redundancy ensures that traffic is automatically rerouted during outages, safeguarding consistent network performance. Additionally, MPLS circuits typically use geographically diverse paths. This diversity helps protect against regional outages, providing a buffer against localized failures. However, the last mile redundancy in MPLS often follows an active-passive approach. This method can delay failover times, potentially interrupting services, particularly latency-sensitive applications like video conferencing.

A significant challenge with MPLS redundancy is the cost factor. The high costs associated with MPLS can render comprehensive redundancy unfeasible for numerous organizations. Moreover, reliance on the same carrier’s infrastructure can leave MPLS susceptible to vulnerabilities unless multiple carriers are engaged. This dependence on a single carrier’s network can be a critical vulnerability, as any significant issue within that network could lead to extensive outages. For businesses requiring high uptime and reliability, the financial burden of MPLS may outweigh its benefits if not strategically balanced with other redundancy methods. Evaluating whether the cost can justify the perceived reliability is crucial in making the right decision for network infrastructure.

SD-WAN Redundancy: Multi-Link Flexibility

SD-WAN offers a more flexible approach to redundancy compared to MPLS. Several critical aspects make it unique: SD-WAN utilizes multi-path connectivity, leveraging diverse options such as MPLS, Ethernet, broadband internet, and 5G. This flexibility allows for seamless rerouting of traffic if one connection fails, maintaining network availability. An active-active redundancy configuration in SD-WAN ensures virtually uninterrupted failover. This method sets SD-WAN apart from the typically slower active-passive MPLS redundancy, making it highly effective for real-time applications. Despite its advantages, SD-WAN has its own set of challenges. Its dependence on internet connectivity can be unreliable compared to the dedicated circuits of MPLS, posing potential risks to network stability and performance.

Another critical point of failure in SD-WAN is the on-premises appliance. This physical device can become a single point of failure, impacting connectivity across all network connections if it malfunctions. Adopting a comprehensive approach that includes multiple redundancy strategies can help mitigate these risks. However, the cost and complexity of managing such systems must be considered. It’s vital to understand that while SD-WAN offers increased flexibility and potential cost savings, it also requires a robust management and monitoring framework to ensure the desired levels of reliability and performance.

SASE Redundancy: Cloud-Based Multi-Layer Resilience

SASE combines the strengths of SD-WAN with comprehensive security functionalities in a single cloud-based solution. Key points for SASE redundancy include: A global network of PoPs (points of presence) connected by multiple top-tier carriers ensures redundant paths. This setup provides fail-safe mechanisms if a single carrier experiences an outage, maintaining service continuity. Automated rerouting of traffic during outages is a significant strength of SASE. Traffic is redirected to alternative carriers or PoPs, ensuring consistent network performance even during disruptions. Redundant compute nodes within each PoP are crucial for processing network traffic and executing centralized security policies. This redundancy ensures that failure in one compute node does not compromise the overall network performance.

SASE’s inherent cloud-native design can also incorporate edge devices for organizations still reliant on physical infrastructure. This hybrid approach can maintain direct internet connectivity even during total SASE cloud failures, providing an extra layer of reliability. Integrating such advanced features into a single solution makes SASE an attractive proposition for organizations looking to enhance their network redundancy. However, implementing SASE requires careful planning to ensure all components, from PoPs to edge devices, are adequately configured and monitored. As organizations increasingly migrate towards cloud services, SASE provides an effective way to ensure network resilience while also addressing security and connectivity needs holistically.

Overarching Trends and Consensus Viewpoints

In today’s digital landscape, the constant availability of IT infrastructure is essential for businesses. Network downtime, even for a minute, can lead to substantial financial losses, sometimes exceeding $14,000, depending on the size of the company and its industry. These high stakes underscore the need for a dependable and robust network infrastructure. This discussion centers on network redundancy, examining it through the lenses of MPLS (Multiprotocol Label Switching), SD-WAN (Software-Defined Wide Area Network), and SASE (Secure Access Service Edge).

The importance of network redundancy can’t be overstated. It ensures that businesses can maintain operations without interruptions, which, in turn, safeguards revenue, boosts employee productivity, and enhances customer satisfaction. These technologies—MPLS, SD-WAN, and SASE—offer different approaches to achieving network redundancy. MPLS provides high-performance connectivity but can be costly. SD-WAN offers flexibility and cost savings by leveraging multiple connection types. Meanwhile, SASE combines network security and wide-area networking, providing a holistic solution.

By understanding these various methods, organizations can make well-informed decisions tailored to their specific needs, thus ensuring business continuity and improving overall efficiency. This knowledge is crucial for maintaining competitive advantage in today’s fast-paced digital world.

Subscribe to our weekly news digest!

Join now and become a part of our fast-growing community.

Invalid Email Address
Thanks for subscribing.
We'll be sending you our best soon.
Something went wrong, please try again later